The Journal Higher education in Russia - a peer-reviewed scholarly journal
ISSN 0869-3617 (Print), ISSN 2072-0459 (Online) Facebook |
.: Menu :.

Higher education in Russia - a peer-reviewed scholarly journal
  • Home
  • About
  • Editorial Board & International Council Members
  • Publication ethics and Author's guide
  • Manuscript submission
  • Peer-review procedure
  • Contacts
  • .: Commercial links :.

    : 10 . 10. :24 300 /.

    .: Peer-review procedure :.

    Peer-review procedure

    1. All the manuscripts submitted to Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii (Higher Education in Russia) are reviewed by the Editor to assess its suitability for the journal according to the guidelines determined by the editorial policy. On this step of the initial filtering the manuscript can be rejected if the content doesn't fall within the scope of the journal or it fails to meet sufficiently our basic criteria and the submission requirements.

    2. The papers accepted for publication are subjected to the single-blind peer review process which can be accomplished either by the members of Editorial staff (Heads of Departments) or by involved additional reviewers (experts from the Russian Academy of Science, Russian Academy of Education, university professors, members of associations and scientific communities, such as Technical Universities Association, IGIP Russian Monitoring Committee (RMC IGIP), Association for Engineering Education of Russia (AEER), Association of the Classical Universities of Russia (ACUR). The assigned reviewers are experts within the scope of the journal and for the last three years have publications in the topic areas of the research papers submitted.

    3. The reviewer evaluates the compliance of the manuscript according to the following principles:

    1) compliance with the thematic scope of the journal;
    2) relevance to the publication guidelines and journal policy;
    3) scientific merit (novelty);
    4) paper evaluation from the point of view of plagiarism (verbatim copying, paraphrasing, re-using parts of a work without attribution) or self-plagiarism using;
    5) presentation and understandability of the paper on the whole, comprehension of the topic area, and the validity of research results;
    6) methodology used (paper's arguments, methods and conclusions);
    7) adequacy of citations and references to other sources;
    8) quality of a text including language style, logics, and general readability.

    4. The reviewer's report should provide one of the following recommendations: a) to accept the paper for publication in the journal Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii (Higher Education in Russia), b) to accept the paper for publication with major or minor revisions according to the reviewer's commentaries and suggestions; 3) to decline paper.

    5. Submission process and peer-review procedure take about 3-6 weeks. Accepted articles are usually published in the order in which they pass the review process, but the editorial board reserves the right to determine the sequence in which articles are published and to publish some papers out of turn.

    6. The approved manuscripts are put into the preparation and production process.

    7. If the manuscript was declined by the editor or the reviewer didn't recommend it for publication the associate editor informs the author about the rejection. In case the manuscript requires revision the associate editor sends the reviewer's report to the author. The revised variant of the paper has to undergo the new peer-review process. The originals of reviews are retained in the editorial office for 5 years.

    8. A copy of reviewer's report is sent to the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation on the corresponding request.

    [ Copyright 2015 The journal Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii (Higher education in Russia) ]